Many businesses offer active-duty and retired
members of the United States’ Armed Forces discounts on products and
services. While this is certainly a commendable practice, it is not
without risk to the business offering the discount. Many such
businesses require some type of verification of a customer’s military
status before qualifying the customer for the offered discount. Many
businesses, including those not offering discounts but needing
verification of identity for other purposes, have adopted the practice
of making a photocopy of the customer’s military identification card.
Doing so, however, while seemingly the easiest way to obtain such
verification, can result in a criminal violation of Federal law.
The statute in question, 18 U.S.C. § 701, does not
require intent or an evil motive, but rather, requires only the simple
act of photocopying a military identification card to establish the
violation.
The statute in question provides:
Whoever
manufactures, sells, or possesses any badge, identification card, or
other insignia, of the design prescribed by the head of any department
or agency of the United States for use by any officer or employee
thereof, or any colorable imitation thereof, or photographs, prints, or
in any other manner makes or executes any engraving, photograph, print,
or impression in the likeness of any such badge, identification card, or
other insignia, or any colorable imitation thereof, except as
authorized under regulations made pursuant to law, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than six months, or both.
(Emphasis added).
If
your business offers military discounts and collects verification of a
customer’s military status, make sure your employees are aware of this
prohibition and, if you have not done so already, a policy should be
adopted and incorporated into your training program to ensure that this
prohibition is known and complied with by your team.
Please
note that the only prohibition arising out of the above statute relates
to photocopying the military identification card. You can ask to see
the customer’s military identification card and can make note of all
information contained on the card, you just cannot photocopy it. If
merely making note of the information on the card is not sufficient for
your internal purposes, you can request that the customer provide
written confirmation of his or her status as a military member from his
or her commanding officer. Alternatively, you can obtain a Service
Members Civil Relief Act Certificate through a public website which
allows businesses to verify the current active military status of
specific individuals. There is no charge for the certificate if obtained
online. You can submit a request for the certificate on the Department
of Defense’s website at
www.defense.gov by searching for “Service Members Civil Relief Act Certificates.”
As
with any blanket prohibition, there are certain exceptions where the
photocopying of military IDs is permitted. There is an exception for
health care providers, which permits them to make photocopies of
military IDs only for the purpose of providing benefits. This exception
can be found in a Department of Defense Instruction issued in 1997, and
provides that civilian and military medical providers are authorized to
photocopy military ID as proof of insurance for the purposes of
providing medical care to Department of Defense beneficiaries.
Another
exception is in connection with an employer’s compliance with the
Immigration and Nationality Act, the federal statute governing the form
I-9 process. This Act expressly permits the photocopying of any
“document presented by an individual pursuant to this subsection.” Since
a military identification card is one of the permissible forms of
identification under this Act, an employer may photocopy the military ID
and retain the copy (only for the purposes of complying with the
Act).
If your business offers military discounts, or has a
practice of photocopying military identification cards for your
business/commercial purposes, make certain your employees are aware of
this prohibition and adjust your policies and procedures accordingly so
you do not become an example of no good deed going unpunished.
If you have any questions regarding your policies or procedures in this area, please seek the advice of competent counsel.